Baffled...I thought I understood Match Date

I have some utility statements I'd like to rename and file. I couldn't get date match to work. I set up a folder with some files named the same way to show you.
The files I want to rename look like this:

I previewed the file with the May 2015 date. This result makes sense to me:

Previewing the same file, this result does not make sense to me:

Here's how I set up the Match Date token:

So there's something I'm not getting about how to set this up. I used forced four digits for the year and two for the month and date. I put a hyphen between the date elements. Thoughts on what I've done wrong?
The files I want to rename look like this:

I previewed the file with the May 2015 date. This result makes sense to me:

Previewing the same file, this result does not make sense to me:

Here's how I set up the Match Date token:

So there's something I'm not getting about how to set this up. I used forced four digits for the year and two for the month and date. I put a hyphen between the date elements. Thoughts on what I've done wrong?