FTP Upload in rule works on one computer, fails on another..

I have a Macbook and a Mac Pro. Both running 10.11.3, both Hazel v3.3.8(1321). I had an identical rule on each that included an SFTP upload. I recently edited the server in the rule and on the Macbook it works fine. I made the same edit on the Mac Pro, and it fails. I deleted the rule and exported the ones on the MacBook, imported on Mc Pro, still failed.
In the log it shows
and
Edit to add: The Mac Pro was working fine before making the change. They were identical before, both worked. Identical now, only one works.
In the log it shows
- Code: Select all
Unable to retrieve internet password for X: -25300 - Error Domain=NSOSStatusErrorDomain Code=-25300 "errKCItemNotFound / errSecItemNotFound: / The item cannot be found."
and
- Code: Select all
Failed trying to get contents of directory for X: Error Domain=NSURLErrorDomain Code=-1202 "The folder “Y” could not be accessed. " UserInfo={NSLocalizedDescription=The folder “Y” could not be accessed. , NSErrorFailingURLStringKey=X, NSErrorFailingURLKey=X, NSLocalizedFailureReason=SSL peer certificate or SSH remote key was not OK}
Edit to add: The Mac Pro was working fine before making the change. They were identical before, both worked. Identical now, only one works.